Reputation Management for DTC Brands

You Paid For The Click, Then they searched your brand and found 1.3 stars.

You are paying for the click and then losing the customer on a page you do not own. Your reviews. Your BBB file. A thread someone wrote two years ago. That is where the decision gets made now, and that is what we rebuild, using your real customers.

What you get

Real reviews, from customers who actually ordered.

Every complaint answered, not left sitting.

Your reputation scored, and re-scored every month.

Reputation Management for DTC Brands

Reputation programs running across supplements, beauty, skincare, home care and consumer apps.

8 / month

Verified reviews earned

100%

BBB complaints answered

90 Days

To a rebuilt rating

300+ brands have changed what buyers find about them

What this is quietly costing you

It never shows up as one line on a dashboard, which is probably why you have been living with it. It shows up as a conversion rate that will not move no matter what you test, a refund rate creeping up, and customers who buy once and never come back. You are paying full price for traffic that changes its mind on the way to your checkout.

  • Acquisition: You already paid for that click. They read your reviews and left.
  • Retention: Nobody reorders from a brand they had to talk themselves into.
  • Risk: Rising disputes and complaints get noticed by processors and ad platforms.

If you spend $200,000 a month and 40 percent check your reviews, half of them walking is $40,000 buying nothing.

Selling software or billing on subscription instead? See Reputation Management for SaaS Brands.

What a poor online reputation costs a brand
What a payment processor sees when reviewing a merchant

What your payment processor sees

Before an acquirer approves you, and every time they review you after, someone reads your reviews. Unresolved complaints, one-star ratings and refund threads all feed your risk score. The complaints that become bad reviews this month are usually the ones that become chargebacks next month. Sell supplements or bill on subscription and you were flagged before any of this started.

  •   Underwriting: Reviews and unresolved complaints feed your risk score at approval and after.

  • Early warning: Complaint volume climbs weeks before the disputes actually land.

  • The cliff: Past roughly 1 percent disputes you are in a monitoring program.

Clearing your complaint backlog is not customer service admin. It is the cheapest insurance you can buy on your ability to take money.

How we rebuild it

Real reviews, from customers who actually ordered

You do not need us to write reviews. You need your customers to actually get asked. We build that: the SOP, the CS script, a card in every box, incentives that pay for asking and never for the rating, and a tracker tied to real orders.

Every complaint answered, not left sitting

An unanswered BBB file tells a customer nobody is listening, and tells an underwriter something worse. We claim the profile, write the response SOP, and work the backlog until every complaint has a reply. One client had 29 of 39 untouched.

We put your side of the story on record

Right now the only version of your brand out there is the one written by unhappy people. We watch wherever you come up, correct what is wrong, answer what is fair, and add real coverage through monthly PR and honest third-party reviews.

Trusted by brands across supplements, beauty, home care and consumer apps.

Book a call and we will show you what your customers find and what it costs you.

Infrastructure & Expertise

A team, not a review widget

Software emails your customers and tells you when a rating drops. It cannot answer a complaint, hold a conversation, or earn you coverage. We do the part software cannot, under one owner.

We have never written a review

Not one, not ever. Every review on your profile comes from a customer who actually ordered. The drafts we give you guide how your team asks, and you can open the tracker and check any request against an order.

No lock-in, and you keep everything

90 days to build the system, then month to month with 30 days notice. If you leave, every review, reply, placement and profile we built stays live and stays yours.

You Will Always Know What Your Reputation Is Doing To Revenue.

Monthly Sentiment Report

Your score, your star split, reply rate, complaint status, and what moved.

Live Dashboard

Reviews in, complaints cleared, coverage live, PR and listings, by month.

Direct Access

Your team is always a Slack message or call away.

Our Proven Process for Building a Strong DTC Brand Reputation

brand sentiment audit

Step 1

Brand Sentiment Audit & Trust Score

We go through your review profiles, star split, reply rate, BBB file, community mentions and what AI says when someone asks about you, then score it out of 10. You see what a customer finds and which parts of it are costing you money.
review and complaint systems build

Step 2

Review & Complaint Systems Build

We write the Trustpilot SOP and the BBB SOP, design the card that goes in the box, set your CS incentive tiers and build the tracker. Your team starts asking real customers and clearing the backlog in week one.
coverage and community management

Step 3

Coverage & Community Management

Monthly PR, and someone watching wherever your brand comes up so it gets a reply the same week. Honest third-party reviews, plus five brand listings so your own profiles are what people find first.
monthly reporting and re-scoring

Step 4

Monthly Reporting & Re-Scoring

We re-score you every month and show you the movement: rating, reply rate, complaints, sentiment, coverage. If something new appears about you, you hear it from us before you hear it from a customer.
brand sentiment audit

Step 2

Review & Complaint Systems Build

We write the Trustpilot SOP and the BBB SOP, design the card that goes in the box, set your CS incentive tiers and build the tracker. Your team starts asking real customers and clearing the backlog in week one.

coverage and community management

Step 4

Monthly Reporting & Re-Scoring

We re-score you every month and show you the movement: rating, reply rate, complaints, sentiment, coverage. If something new appears about you, you hear it from us before you hear it from a customer.

Step 1

Brand Sentiment Audit & Trust Score

We go through your review profiles, star split, reply rate, BBB file, community mentions and what AI says when someone asks about you, then score it out of 10. You see what a customer finds and which parts of it are costing you money.

review and complaint systems build

Step 3

Coverage & Community Management

Monthly PR, and someone watching wherever your brand comes up so it gets a reply the same week. Honest third-party reviews, plus five brand listings so your own profiles are what people find first.

monthly reporting and re-scoring

8 / month

Verified reviews earned

100%

BBB complaints answered

90 Days

To a rebuilt rating

What a rebuilt reputation looks like

  • Supplement brand: 1.3 stars, 91 percent one-star, zero replies. Real reviews inside a month.
  • Home care brand: 29 of 39 BBB complaints untouched. Response SOP running in month one.
  • Beauty brand: 28 verified reviews at a 4.9 average, every one tied to a real order.

Reputation management built to protect revenue

Where you actually stand across reviews, BBB, mentions and AI answers.

SOP, card, CS incentives, tracker, and 8 verified reviews every month.

Clear the backlog underwriters read, and get the rating moving again.

Someone watching where you come up, replying the same week it happens.

One earned release a month plus honest reviews from people who use it.

Re-scored monthly, with new problems flagged before they spread.

DTC Reputation Management FAQs

No, and we never have. Every review comes from a customer who actually ordered. The drafts we give you guide how your team asks, and you can audit any request against an order.

Only where one breaks platform policy, and we will tell you which qualify. The rest get answered. A rating recovers on real volume and visible replies, not on deletions.

It depends on where your score sits, how many reviews you have and how big the complaint backlog is. A brand with no profile is a different build from one at 1,800 reviews.

Complaint replies go out in week one and reviews start landing inside the first month. A rating moves properly over 90 days. Sentiment shifts over two to three quarters.

They feed into it. Underwriters check reviews and unresolved complaints when scoring risk, and complaints usually rise weeks before disputes do. We fix those signals. We are not payment consultants.

Not the way we run it. Every request ties to a verified order and incentives pay for the ask, never for the rating. Every touch sits in a tracker you can open.

90 days to build the system, then month to month with 30 days notice. Everything we published stays live and stays yours if you decide to stop working with us.

That is easier. A blank profile looks risky to a buyer but there is no damage to undo. We start with acquisition and listings before a negative pattern ever forms.

No. It changes how both convert. Reputation work rarely adds new traffic. It stops you losing the traffic and the customers you already pay for.

No, and we never have. Every review comes from a customer who actually ordered. The drafts we give you guide how your team asks, and you can audit any request against an order.

Only where one breaks platform policy, and we will tell you which qualify. The rest get answered. A rating recovers on real volume and visible replies, not on deletions.

It depends on where your score sits, how many reviews you have and how big the complaint backlog is. A brand with no profile is a different build from one at 1,800 reviews.

Complaint replies go out in week one and reviews start landing inside the first month. A rating moves properly over 90 days. Sentiment shifts over two to three quarters.

They feed into it. Underwriters check reviews and unresolved complaints when scoring risk, and complaints usually rise weeks before disputes do. We fix those signals. We are not payment consultants.

Not the way we run it. Every request ties to a verified order and incentives pay for the ask, never for the rating. Every touch sits in a tracker you can open.

90 days to build the system, then month to month with 30 days notice. Everything we published stays live and stays yours if you decide to stop working with us.

That is easier. A blank profile looks risky to a buyer but there is no damage to undo. We start with acquisition and listings before a negative pattern ever forms.

No. It changes how both convert. Reputation work rarely adds new traffic. It stops you losing the traffic and the customers you already pay for.

See what your customers see

Book a free reputation assessment. We walk you through your reviews, your BBB file, what people say about you and what AI repeats back, and we score it out of 10. Thirty minutes, and you keep the score either way.

You keep the score and the plan either way.

 

Your reputation scored out of 10

Every review, complaint and mention costing you orders

The three fixes we would make first, in order

A 90-day rebuild plan with monthly deliverables

Your reputation scored out of 10

Every review, complaint and mention costing you orders

The three fixes we would make first, in order

A 90-day rebuild plan with monthly deliverables

Brandon Longo

Brandon Longo is the Founder and CEO of Organic Checkout, an ecommerce growth agency specializing in SEO, Google ads, online reputation management, and organic customer acquisition for direct-to-consumer and subscription brands.

 

As both an agency owner and ecommerce operator, Brandon brings a practical understanding of what it takes to build and scale a profitable online business. His experience spans supplements, health and wellness, professional services, and high-growth consumer brands, giving him a unique perspective that connects search visibility with conversion rates, retention, brand trust, and long-term profitability.

 

Under Brandon’s leadership, Organic Checkout has grown into a multidisciplinary agency supported by Google Ads strategists, technical SEO, content strategy, digital PR, reputation management, development, and analytics. His approach focuses on creating measurable business outcomes.

Rin Mosher

Rin Mosher is a content specialist who knows – and writes – it all. Her professional background encompasses in-house and agency work spanning industries and clientele from ecommerce to law to SaaS. With the world’s focus shifting, Rin’s latest focus has been developing skills that mean something in the future of marketing, specifically AI-optimized content development and full funnel, socially-driven campaign strategy and execution. She also builds websites, manages email projects, and helps business owners brand and run their online stores

Madison Angus

Madison Angus is a strategic client growth professional with 8+ years of experience spanning digital marketing, branding, communications, sales, and account management. She specializes in building strong client relationships and translating business goals into thoughtful, results-driven strategies. At Organic Checkout, Madison works closely with clients to uncover opportunities, strengthen their digital presence, and create sustainable paths forward. Her background in creative industries brings a unique perspective to her work, blending analytical thinking with storytelling and a deep understanding of audiences. Outside of work, Madison is passionate about music, travel, creativity, and continually discovering new perspectives and experiences.

Miroslav

Miroslav is a Senior Technical SEO Specialist at Organic Checkout, where he focuses on the technical side of search. He conducts deep-dive audits and implements fixes across WordPress and Shopify, primarily using Semrush and Sitebulb.

 

His work centers on crawl efficiency, indexing recovery, site speed, and Core Web Vitals, ensuring priority pages remain healthy across multiple client websites. He uses Google Search Console daily to monitor performance and resolve large-scale indexing issues.

 

Alongside his technical SEO work, Miroslav manages Google Business Profile optimization for local and service-area brands, covering categories, posting schedules, NAP consistency, and map pack visibility. He brings more than seven years of experience in organic growth, supported by an extensive background in data analysis and development that shapes his approach to solving complex problems.

Shawn McCrory

Shawn McCrory believes great work begins with asking the right questions and having enough empathy to consider and accept the different perspectives reflected in the answers.

 

That mindset took shape early in his professional journey, following an academic background rooted in the humanities, particularly history, professional writing, and translation. At its core, Shawn’s philosophy is simple: if you cannot put yourself in the shoes of your clients and their customers, you will struggle to identify the right problems, let alone develop the right solutions.

 

Since then, this outlook has supported a diverse career spanning freelance writing, marketing for brick-and-mortar businesses, SEO content strategy, and account management.

 

Outside of work, Shawn is a devoted father to two energetic children. His hobbies tend to keep him active and hands-on, with cooking, gardening, exercising, and coaching youth soccer taking up much of his free time.

Fredrick

Fredrick is a senior SEO strategist with almost a decade experience specializing in building and managing advanced SEO architecture, strategic search intent mapping, and market-leader execution,

 

Fredrick turns organic channels into predictable revenue drivers. He brings deep expertise in aligning broad client growth goals with data-driven search strategies, effortlessly bridging executive vision and technical execution.

 

Known for his ability to navigate high-competition verticals, Fredrick helps clients scale their organic footprint, expand client visibility in the AI age, and deliver measurable, enterprise-level performance aligned with business goals.

Greg

is the Director of SEO Strategy at Organic Checkout, where he leads client strategy, reporting, team processes, and the integration of AI into modern search marketing. He enjoys turning complex data into clear, practical plans that help brands grow across SEO, GEO, content, and performance marketing. Outside of work, Greg is passionate about fitness, technology, and continuous learning. He regularly trains, plays hockey and basketball, and enjoys exploring new tools that improve productivity and creativity. He also values time with family and friends and is always looking for new ways to challenge himself, grow professionally, and support others.

Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success